b549548f69
The code in Spack to generate install and test reports currently suffers from unneeded complexity. For instance, we have classes in Spack core packages, like `spack.reporters.CDash`, that need an `argparse.Namespace` to be initialized and have "hard-coded" string literals on which they branch to change their behavior: ```python if do_fn.__name__ == "do_test" and skip_externals: package["result"] = "skipped" else: package["result"] = "success" package["stdout"] = fetch_log(pkg, do_fn, self.dir) package["installed_from_binary_cache"] = pkg.installed_from_binary_cache if do_fn.__name__ == "_install_task" and installed_already: return ``` This PR attempt to polish the major issues encountered in both `spack.report` and `spack.reporters`. Details: - [x] `spack.reporters` is now a package that contains both the base class `Reporter` and all the derived classes (`JUnit` and `CDash`) - [x] Classes derived from `spack.reporters.Reporter` don't take an `argparse.Namespace` anymore as argument to `__init__`. The rationale is that code for commands should be built upon Spack core classes, not vice-versa. - [x] An `argparse.Action` has been coded to create the correct `Reporter` object based on command line arguments - [x] The context managers to generate reports from either `spack install` or from `spack test` have been greatly simplified, and have been made less "dynamic" in nature. In particular, the `collect_info` class has been deleted in favor of two more specific context managers. This allows for a simpler structure of the code, and less knowledge required to client code (in particular on which method to patch) - [x] The `InfoCollector` class has been turned into a simple hierarchy, so to avoid conditional statements within methods that assume a knowledge of the context in which the method is called. |
||
---|---|---|
.. | ||
spack |