lock transactions: avoid redundant reading in write transactions

Our `LockTransaction` class was reading overly aggressively.  In cases
like this:

```
1  with spack.store.db.read_transaction():
2    with spack.store.db.write_transaction():
3      ...
```

The `ReadTransaction` on line 1 would read in the DB, but the
WriteTransaction on line 2 would read in the DB *again*, even though we
had a read lock the whole time.  `WriteTransaction`s were only
considering nested writes to decide when to read, but they didn't know
when we already had a read lock.

- [x] `Lock.acquire_write()` return `False` in cases where we already had
       a read lock.
This commit is contained in:
Todd Gamblin 2019-12-21 16:31:28 -08:00
parent bb517fdb84
commit 6c9467e8c6
2 changed files with 62 additions and 1 deletions

View file

@ -275,7 +275,12 @@ def acquire_write(self, timeout=None):
wait_time, nattempts = self._lock(fcntl.LOCK_EX, timeout=timeout)
self._acquired_debug('WRITE LOCK', wait_time, nattempts)
self._writes += 1
return True
# return True only if we weren't nested in a read lock.
# TODO: we may need to return two values: whether we got
# the write lock, and whether this is acquiring a read OR
# write lock for the first time. Now it returns the latter.
return self._reads == 0
else:
self._writes += 1
return False

View file

@ -1087,6 +1087,62 @@ def write(t, v, tb):
assert vals['wrote']
def test_nested_reads(lock_path):
"""Ensure that write transactions won't re-read data."""
def read():
vals['read'] += 1
vals = collections.defaultdict(lambda: 0)
lock = AssertLock(lock_path, vals)
# read/read
vals.clear()
assert vals['read'] == 0
with lk.ReadTransaction(lock, acquire=read):
assert vals['read'] == 1
with lk.ReadTransaction(lock, acquire=read):
assert vals['read'] == 1
# write/write
vals.clear()
assert vals['read'] == 0
with lk.WriteTransaction(lock, acquire=read):
assert vals['read'] == 1
with lk.WriteTransaction(lock, acquire=read):
assert vals['read'] == 1
# read/write
vals.clear()
assert vals['read'] == 0
with lk.ReadTransaction(lock, acquire=read):
assert vals['read'] == 1
with lk.WriteTransaction(lock, acquire=read):
assert vals['read'] == 1
# write/read/write
vals.clear()
assert vals['read'] == 0
with lk.WriteTransaction(lock, acquire=read):
assert vals['read'] == 1
with lk.ReadTransaction(lock, acquire=read):
assert vals['read'] == 1
with lk.WriteTransaction(lock, acquire=read):
assert vals['read'] == 1
# read/write/read/write
vals.clear()
assert vals['read'] == 0
with lk.ReadTransaction(lock, acquire=read):
assert vals['read'] == 1
with lk.WriteTransaction(lock, acquire=read):
assert vals['read'] == 1
with lk.ReadTransaction(lock, acquire=read):
assert vals['read'] == 1
with lk.WriteTransaction(lock, acquire=read):
assert vals['read'] == 1
def test_lock_debug_output(lock_path):
host = socket.getfqdn()